[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]
Re: Freedom and security
At 7:38 PM 4/30/96, [email protected] (CyberAngels Director : Colin
Gabriel Hatche wrote:
>My concern is not so much with network sabotage or infiltration (there are
>plenty enough organizations addressing that problem) but with personal
>safety within the Internet community - that means you, not your hard drive.
This is a totally facetious point. I am fully capable of protecting myself
and my family from ANY threat posed by a single individual over the
internet (and from most threats posed in person as well). There is no
"personal safety" issue. This is fantasy. When someone dies from an email
message, come back and talk to me about security. Until then, the biggest
threat to my security on the internet comes from groups such as yours and
from the government. In attempting to limit access to anonymous remailers
and cryptography, you are attempting to limit my ability to protect myself,
while substituting dubious governmental protection. I say dubious, because
in the real world, there will always be those who break the law (if
cryptography is outlawed...).
You do have one point I agree with:
>Freedom of speech cannot function without law.
This is absolutely correct. There must be a law to protect the freedom of
speech, and we have that law, it is called the 1st amendment to the
Constitution. I saw a .sig the other day that said "What part of 'Congress
shall make no law ... abridging the freedom of speech' do you not
understand" (unfortunately I don't remeber whose .sig it was). The self
anointed internet censors often try to muck up the basic issue of free
speech with the "evil" pornographers and bombmakers theme in an attempt at
convincing the public to give up freedom for illusory security. You fall
in that net.censor category, in that you are attempting to restrict
freedom. Although you may actually believe in what you are doing, you are
wrong. Fortunately, I still have the right to disagree strongly.
Clay
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Clay Olbon II | [email protected]
Systems Engineer | ph: (810) 589-9930 fax 9934
Dynetics, Inc., Ste 302 | http://www.msen.com/~olbon/olbon.html
550 Stephenson Hwy | PGP262 public key: on web page
Troy, MI 48083-1109 | pgp print: B97397AD50233C77523FD058BD1BB7C0
TANSTAAFL
---------------------------------------------------------------------------