[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

Egalitarianism vs. Strong Cryptography



-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----

In Message-Id: <[email protected]>, Mike Duvos
wrote:

> No personal attack intended.  I am a strong supporter of
> egalitarian societies with strong social safety nets, and think
> that youth emancipation will likely be the next big civil rights
> movement in this country.  I am also willing to pay high taxes in
> order to feel secure that all citizen-units are suitably housed,
> well-fed, and taken care of.  This is entirely self-serving on my
> part, since it cuts down on social unrest and street crime.

Yet in the present message he observes that

> The lesson to be learned here is that societies based on a
> diffuse "Web of Trust" organization are far less dangerous than
> those based on a powerful centralized authority.  A powerful
> centralized authority inevitably devolves into interacting with
> its subjects using the protocol...

>            Do What We Say Or We'll Kill You!

> Or in its more tasteful two-part form...

>            1.  Do What We Say.
>            2.  You're Under Arrest, And If You Resist,
>                We'll Kill You.

> At that point, Wars, Wacos, Encryption Bans, and BBS Porno Show
> trials lurk just around the corner.

Mike Duvos, how I wish I had the time to try to understand how you
reconcile these seemingly incompatible sentiments!

How can you achieve ``egalitarian societies with strong social safety
nets'' without using ``powerful centralized authority''?  As a proponent
of ``high taxes'', how can you also favor strong cryptography?  Do you
doubt that expropriating ``high taxes'' from your neighbor will be made
more difficult in a world with strong cryptography?  In view of the
natural diversity among people, how can you achieve an ``egalitarian
society'' without someone who says ``Do What We Say Or We'll Kill
You!''?

	John E. Kreznar		| Relations among people to be by
	[email protected]	| mutual consent, or not at all.

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: 2.3a

iQCVAgUBLj9zc8Dhz44ugybJAQE/fwP/TA+yCerTZk8pH1Gi2yunA0FE8FqKm7i+
Gy8URq3jFOUPYDHy6fkFPsfX8NB404e1eGFFBNx6U0FE360FmYKO7eI+q5dUJ9gE
fBLKlQYL/HSGyoPs6P4ZYJxNwY0svCUwOnOTIcVAb2UEHdHlDF+cvsogOFJk3WIy
w/9kwSsE20s=
=TM1s
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----