[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]
Re: Untraceable Payments, Extortion, and Other Bad Things
>You obviously (deliberately?) are misrepresenting May's comment above. It
>isn't that some kinds of evil are "no big deal": It's that quantiatively,
>refusing to accept a solution that would prevent, say, 100 deaths, simply
>because it would cause _one_ DIFFERENT death is foolish and misguided.
>
>If you feel inclined to deny this, consider the reverse situation: Would
>you approve of the saving of one life if it cost 100 lives? (all things
>being equal.) While most people would feel uncomfortable being asked to
>make decisions of this kind, that does not mean that one outcome is not
>identifiably better than another.
*I* am misrepresenting Timmy's statement?
please explain to me how anonymous extortion and kidnapping/ransom (what
Timmy was talking about) saves lives along the lines of the above
reasoning...