[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

Re: Banking Secrecy and Nazi Gold



[email protected] writes:
> 
> At 07:50 PM 5/7/97 -0500, Igor Chudov @ home wrote:
> >According to americal common law, as I understand it, no one can get
> >a valid title to the property from someone who did not have such title.
> >
> >E.g., if you steal Vulis's car and then sell it to me, I will not have
> >the title to the car and will have to return it back to Vulis (and may
> >be able to try to recover my loss from you). The same will be true if
> >you lend the stolen car to me -- he can get it back if he proves that it
> >is his.
> 
> The thief's ownership of personal property is good against the whole world
> save the true owner. 
> 
> "18. In general, possession constitutes the criterion of title of 
> personal property, because no other means exist by which a knowledge of the 
> fact to whom it belongs can be attained. A seller of a chattel is not, 
> therefore, required to show the origin of his title, nor, in general, is a 
> purchaser, without notice of the claim of the owner, compellable to make 
> restitution; but, it seems, that a purchaser from a tenant for life of 
> personal chattels, will not be secure against the claims of those entitled 
> in remainder. Cowp. 432; 1 Bro. C. C. 274; 2 T. R. 376; 3 Atk. 44; 3 V. & B. 
> 16."
> 

My problem with Igor's model is that has a "gubmint" that can decide that
although you possess something, you don't have a title to it.

I don't think the cost of having a "gubmint" justifies the convenience(?)
of having one's stolen property recovered.

I point Igor's attention to the two categories of real estate ownership in
traditional Russian legal framework (probably borrowed from Poland and
Germany...) - the kind that cannot be taken away by the state for any
reasn (even as punishment for treason), and the kind that can be taken
away, e.g., for non-paymet of taxes.

---

<a href="mailto:[email protected]">Dr.Dimitri Vulis KOTM</a>
Brighton Beach Boardwalk BBS, Forest Hills, N.Y.: +1-718-261-2013, 14.4Kbps